How does the UK's legal system handle appeals

Grounds and Right to Appeal

Generally, if you lose a case, you have a right to appeal, but this right is not automatic in all situations. Appeals must be based on proper grounds, such as an error of law, a procedural irregularity, or a decision that is deemed unsafe or unjust. Appeals focus on the decision made, not on re-arguing the entire case from scratch.

Hierarchy and Courts Involved in Appeals

Magistrates’ Courts: Appeals against decisions in magistrates’ courts are heard by the Crown Court. The appeal is lodged at the magistrates’ court, which forwards the paperwork to the Crown Court for a hearing.
Crown Court: For criminal cases tried in the Crown Court, appeals against conviction or sentence are made to the Court of Appeal Criminal Division. However, permission (leave) to appeal must be obtained before proceeding.
County Courts and High Court: Appeals in civil cases from county courts or the High Court are mostly heard by the Court of Appeal Civil Division.
Court of Appeal: This court has two divisions: the Civil Division and the Criminal Division. The Civil Division hears appeals from the High Court, county courts, and family courts, while the Criminal Division hears appeals from the Crown Court and military courts.
Supreme Court: The highest court in the UK hears appeals on points of law of the greatest public or constitutional importance after cases have been through the Court of Appeal.

Permission to Appeal

Most appeals require permission, either from the lower court or the appellate court. This is a filter to ensure only cases with a real prospect of success or some compelling reason proceed. Applications for permission are usually made to the court that made the original decision but can be made directly to the appellate court if refused initially.

Appeal Process and Documentation

To start an appeal, the appellant must file specific documents, including an appellant’s notice outlining the grounds of appeal, a skeleton argument summarising key points, and a sealed copy of the decision being challenged. Court fees apply, with fees varying depending on whether the appeal is made directly or after permission is granted.

Types of Appeals and Hearings

The Court of Appeal generally conducts appeals as reviews based on the record of the original trial, without rehearing evidence or witnesses. However, in certain circumstances, a full rehearing can be ordered if the interests of justice require it. Appeals can challenge convictions, sentences, or procedural decisions made during the trial.

Criminal Appeals

In criminal cases, the Court of Appeal Criminal Division reviews appeals against conviction and sentence. The court can quash convictions it finds unsafe or reduce sentences deemed excessive. The Attorney General can also refer cases where a sentence is considered unduly lenient. The Criminal Division may hear fresh evidence if it is necessary in the interests of justice but typically relies on the trial record.

Civil Appeals

Civil appeals cover a wide range of disputes, including contractual disagreements, personal injury claims, family law matters, and judicial reviews of public authority decisions. The Court of Appeal Civil Division can uphold, reverse, or modify decisions from the lower courts.

Finality and Further Appeals

Decisions of the Court of Appeal are usually final, but in exceptional cases, parties may seek permission to appeal to the Supreme Court. The Supreme Court hears only cases involving significant legal principles or constitutional issues.

This appeals framework ensures fairness and accountability in the UK legal system by providing a clear path to challenge and review judicial decisions while maintaining judicial efficiency and finality.

Appeals must be based on valid legal grounds and are subject to strict time limits.

Lower court decisions can be appealed to the next highest court, with magistrates’ decisions going to the Crown Court, and Crown Court and High Court decisions going to the Court of Appeal.
Permission to appeal is generally required to filter cases.
The Court of Appeal reviews cases mostly on the existing record but can order rehearings in special circumstances.
Criminal and civil appeals are handled by separate divisions within the Court of Appeal.
The Supreme Court is the final appellate court for important legal questions.

What Happens If You Can’t Afford a Lawyer in the UK?

Worried about legal costs and unsure how to get help if you can’t afford a lawyer? Discover how the UK’s legal aid system can support you by covering legal fees based on your financial circumstances. Learn about eligibility criteria, exceptions, and alternative options like pro bono services to ensure you don’t face legal challenges alone. Find out more in our detailed guide on What Happens If You Can’t Afford a Lawyer UK.

What Is the Difference Between a Lawyer and a Solicitor in the UK?

Confused by legal terminology? Understand the key differences between a lawyer and a solicitor in the UK, including their roles, responsibilities, and how they fit into the legal system. This clear and informative article helps you know who to approach for your legal needs and what to expect from each professional. Read more about What Is the Difference Between a Lawyer and a Solicitor UK.

Legal services in London